Christmas Cactus vs Kalanchoe
The Christmas cactus is pet-safe and wants indirect light and regular water. The kalanchoe needs full sun and almost none, and is toxic to cats and dogs.
Christmas Cactus is non-toxic to cats and dogs. Kalanchoe is toxic to cats and dogs if chewed, so it needs a shelf pets cannot reach. Christmas Cactus needs medium indirect light (3/5) - near a bright window, out of direct sun. Kalanchoe wants bright indirect light (4/5), beside a bright window, no midday sun on the leaves.
What they share: both are rated easy.
Choose
Christmas Cactus if…
- ✓your spot is the dimmer of the two - it manages on medium indirect light
- ✓you like a plant that asks for attention on a schedule
- ✓it will live in a bathroom, kitchen or a humidified room
- ✓cats or dogs chew your plants - this one is non-toxic
- ✓you want a floor-filling plant (30-90 cm (1-3 ft))
Choose
Kalanchoe if…
- ✓you have a bright window to give it (bright indirect light)
- ✓you forget to water - it prefers to dry out between drinks
- ✓your home runs dry in winter and you will not add a humidifier
- ✓it can go somewhere pets genuinely cannot reach
- ✓shelf space is what you have (15-30 cm (6-12 in))
Christmas Cactus vs Kalanchoe: side by side
| Attribute |
Christmas Cactus
|
Kalanchoe
|
|---|---|---|
| Plant type | Cactus | Flowering |
| Difficulty | easy | easy |
| Light | ●●●○○ 3/5 Medium indirect light |
●●●●○ 4/5 Bright indirect light |
| Water | ●●●○○ 3/5 Moderate |
●●○○○ 2/5 Low |
| Humidity | ●●●○○ 3/5 Average |
●○○○○ 1/5 Low |
| Pet safe | Safe | Toxic to cats and dogs |
| Mature size | Medium 30-90 cm (1-3 ft) |
Small 15-30 cm (6-12 in) |
| Growth rate | Moderate | Moderate |
| Air purifying | No | No |
| Native to | Brazil | Madagascar |
Key differences between Christmas Cactus and Kalanchoe
Christmas Cactus is pet-safe, Kalanchoe is not
Christmas Cactus is non-toxic to cats and dogs. Kalanchoe is toxic to cats and dogs if chewed, so it needs a shelf pets cannot reach.
Christmas Cactus copes with less light
Christmas Cactus needs medium indirect light (3/5) - near a bright window, out of direct sun. Kalanchoe wants bright indirect light (4/5), beside a bright window, no midday sun on the leaves.
Christmas Cactus drinks more
Kalanchoe wants low watering (2/5) - water when the top 3-5 cm of soil has dried out. Christmas Cactus needs moderate watering (3/5): water when the top 2-3 cm is dry, roughly weekly.
Christmas Cactus needs damper air
Christmas Cactus rates 3/5 for humidity - normal household humidity works. Kalanchoe rates 1/5, so ordinary dry room air is fine.
Christmas Cactus is the bigger plant
Christmas Cactus reaches 30-90 cm (1-3 ft) and belongs on a side table or plant stand. Kalanchoe tops out around 15-30 cm (6-12 in), so it suits a shelf or desk.
Different plant types: cactus vs flowering
Christmas Cactus is a cactus plant and Kalanchoe is a flowering plant, so they fill different jobs in a room even when their care overlaps.
They come from different habitats
Christmas Cactus originates in Brazil; Kalanchoe in Madagascar. Matching the original habitat is the quickest way to guess what each one wants indoors.
How to tell Christmas Cactus and Kalanchoe apart
The Christmas cactus is a jungle cactus -- it wants indirect light, regular water, and a cool dark autumn to set buds, and it is safe for pets. The kalanchoe is a true succulent that needs direct sun, very little water, and is toxic to cats and dogs.
Care at a glance
Christmas Cactus
Schlumbergera, Holiday Cactus
Trailing cactus that blooms in winter. Different varieties bloom at different holidays.
Care in one line: Bright indirect light, even moisture, cool temps and darkness trigger blooms.
Full Christmas Cactus care guide →
Kalanchoe
Kalanchoe Blossfeldiana, Flaming Katy
Succulent with clusters of bright flowers. Easy to rebloom.
Care in one line: Bright light, water when dry, short days trigger blooming.
Full Kalanchoe care guide →Christmas Cactus vs Kalanchoe: common questions
What is the difference between Christmas Cactus and Kalanchoe? +
The Christmas cactus is a jungle cactus -- it wants indirect light, regular water, and a cool dark autumn to set buds, and it is safe for pets. The kalanchoe is a true succulent that needs direct sun, very little water, and is toxic to cats and dogs. On care, christmas Cactus is non-toxic to cats and dogs. Kalanchoe is toxic to cats and dogs if chewed, so it needs a shelf pets cannot reach.
Which is easier to care for, Christmas Cactus or Kalanchoe? +
Neither - both are rated easy. The practical difference is christmas cactus is pet-safe, kalanchoe is not.
Is Christmas Cactus or Kalanchoe safe for cats and dogs? +
Christmas Cactus is non-toxic to cats and dogs. Kalanchoe is toxic to cats and dogs if chewed, so keep it out of reach or choose the Christmas Cactus.
Which needs less light, Christmas Cactus or Kalanchoe? +
Christmas Cactus. It scores 3/5 for light and near a bright window, out of direct sun. Kalanchoe scores 4/5 and beside a bright window, no midday sun on the leaves.
Which needs more water, Christmas Cactus or Kalanchoe? +
Christmas Cactus, at 3/5 - water when the top 2-3 cm is dry, roughly weekly. Kalanchoe scores 2/5: water when the top 3-5 cm of soil has dried out.
Comparing something else?
Put any two or three of our 116 houseplants head to head on light, water, humidity, size and pet safety.
Build your own comparison →